Archive for the ‘Mahalo’ Category

Dear Jason, Ideas to Fix Mahalo’s problems.

Monday, September 10th, 2007

Dear Jason Calacanis,

I was visiting your blog today, and I noticed that Advertising Age today and noticed Mark Simon criticized Mahalo. Evidently, he’s can’t believe that human powered search can work. He specifically says:

6. “HUMAN-POWERED” SEARCH ENGINES.
The reason search engines are much better places to find information than directories is because they leverage automation to do the grunt work that human editors used to do.

Well, Jason, I can’t help but agree. As I’ve pointed out, the guides you have working on Mahalo are having some difficulty applying the style guide, catching dead links, and catching sneaky redirects that appear after the page is published. Still, I know you plan to persist in the insane endeavor you call “Mahalo”.

As long as you are, I’d like to make a few suggestions. I think you will recognize the underlying goal of each: Let computers and ‘bot do what they do well, let humans do what they do well!

So, here goes: (more…)

Mahalo Follow: As fun as Pac Man!

Saturday, August 18th, 2007

Dear Jason,
Following your recommendation, I installed “Mahalo Follow”. I’m happy to report that I haven’t had so much fun since I played my first video game. Congratulations on discovering Mahalo’s true calling: entertainment!

When I first read that one of the Mahalo Follow’s features was its ability to detect relevant links to a web site viewed in the browser, I thought, “What fun!” So, I eagerly dashed to your blog to give Mahalo Follow’s “concurrent search” a test. (I saw that this morning you were requesting your readers Stumble something or other. Brilliant post, btw.)

Of course, Mahalo Follow was everything I expected. It figured out the the content on your today’s blog entries are is somehow associated with “Pink”, “Peaches”, “Scott Storch” and “Christina Aguilara”. Amazing!

Calacanis asks for Stumble

I understand Danny Sullivan had the gall to criticize Mahalo Follow for “funky” results. Evidently, he thinks Mahalo is flawed because it returns results like “Elton John” when you search “Simpsons movie”.

You, Jason patiently explained that the keyword correlation is poor because Mahalo itself contains so few search results. That’s telling Danny!

Clearly, when a web page (like yours) contain words that have been included in Mahalo search, the results are great!

After all, the terrific results like one I just showed were based on keywords contained both in your blog post and Mahalo search, including: “mahalo, comments, email, covers, silicon, reporter, alley, berry, ombudsman, follow, pink, ping, any, feedback, dmozodp, editors, weekend, los, off, love”.


But does Mahalo do as well if we visit other people’s pages?

I was so inspired by the first result, I thought I’d check out articles listed in Mahalo press coverage . (BTW. I like the dolphins on that browser extension. I bet you picked dolphins because their silly tricks are so entertaining, right? )

I always enjoy Mashable, so I clicked the link to their review of your nifty dolphin encrusted plugin extension. I must say, their title, Mahalo Follow Offers Poor Comparative Search Tools, is rather harsh. The comments in that article were even harsher.

Imagine, someone named “Marc” said, “…but the execution is worthlessly uninspired and no more usable than a generic phpLinkDirectory site.”

So unjustified! How can something as entertaining as Mahalo be called unusable?

Who could fail to delight in the discovery that Mashable’s discussion of your nifty new video-game like browser extension matches your splendid article, “How to Book a Cheap Flight”?

Mashable = Book Cheap Flights

Wow!

(That splendid match is based on these key terms: “about mahalo, search, follow, results, post, poor, offers, new, comparative, tools, trackbacks, related, entries, well, better, sites, next, feature, comment, browser.” )

So, congratulations Jason. Surfing the web is more enjoyable than ever now that I can view Mahalo search results in the sidebar. I’m predict great success now that you have decided to focus on what Mahalo does best: info-tainment!

Sincerely,

P.S. I also enjoyed the sidebar results when I visited Wikipedia’s page on Genesis. I was nearly overcome when I saw that Bartleby’s entry for the bible matches “Spiderman” and “Spider-man Films”, and Google’s search on “double crochet” matches “Indian National Cricket Team”.

Mahalo Search Results: Full of Ads.

Friday, August 17th, 2007

Yesterday, Allan Stern posted Jason Calacanis, the founder of Mahalo, and Melinda part time guide at Mahalo, posted to defend Mahalo’s search results.

In the course of the conversation, Melinda, who does not like Kielbasa, described the process of creating the search results for the Kielbasa search results page. She said:

I put my best finger forward and created what I think is a page that were one to search for Kielbasa they would find the needed information without having to look through hundreds of results as I did. I ran into numerous pages of supposed Kielbasa recipes only to be linked to pages full of advertisements.

(Emphasis added.)

Mahalo Top Seven KielbasaMind you, I’m not sure I, or anyone, knows what the “needed information” is when one searches for “kielbasa”. That said, Mahalo’s top seven results are shown to the right. Most contain ads; I’ve circled the ones I consider riddled with ads.

Still, if Melinda is correct, we will find “the needed information” on these pages that percolated up as she sorted through hundreds of results available on Google. Presumably, we will find also find fewer ads and/or better information than on results returned by Google.

Comparison shows just as many (if not more) ads on Mahalo search results as on Google search results.

(more…)