Who Doesn’t Love Daegan Spam?
Or “Delete to Avoid a Google Penalty”
Or “Delete to Avoid a Google Penalty”
Fantastic! Someone thinks my post is fantastic!! See?
Daegan wrote a fantastic post today on “Dear John Reese: Are Tampon Sample â
Admittedly, the author is a bit muddled about my name, but they dropped me a link. Isn’t that exciting?! …Well….No. I know if I leave the trackback, my blog risks a Google penalty!
That trackback will soon link into a “bad neighborhood”. If you read further, you’ll discover why out-link to bad neighborhood’s could cause Google’s algorithm to suspect a blogger of posting paid links resulting in Google penalty!
But first: How to identify “Daegan Spam”:
- A trackback will quote some of your post, nearly always attributing your words to someone else. I’ve been called “Daegan”, “AnnPlugged” and a variety of other names.
- Often, the “Blog” consists of nothing but very, very short quotes. They don’t violate copyright and won’t cause you duplicate content issues. This may lead you to shrug it off and permit the trackback.
- On some blogs — when the spam is fresh- the collection of links are sort of interesting.
For example, today, a link lead me to a forum where someone advertised a LinkShield Link Protection, a service that will cloak affiliate links. That’s a type of product I might want to learn more about.
So, if you are aware of the danger, the spam is pretty easy to identify. Yet, it seems innocuous doesn’t it?
How could a link to that blog result in a Google penalty?
As the spammy trackback ages, the blog content becomes truly spammy. Idea Hustle, which originally left a trackback on my Duplicate Content Plugin, now redirects to a probably worthless paintball directory site, which could become anything in future.
If I leave this link in place and allow it to “follow”, I suspect I will soon be linking into into a site Google considers to fall in a “bad neighborhood”.
That’s bad for me because we know:
- Google’s algorithm examines what we link to determine our trust and page ranks.
- That paintball link look very spammy; after all, bloggers are often paid to link to these sorts of products.
- Google has been penalizing even very good sites for anything Google considers or suspect to be a paid link.
So, clearly we need to keep links like that off our blogs — especially if we “dofollow”. Luckily, the solution is easy!
Send “Daegen Spam” to Akismet!
Sending these to Akismet gets it of my blog, and also protects all blogs from this sort of spam.
Better yet, even if I miss one or two of these, I never actually give these places a dofollow. Lucia’s Linky Love won’t give the follow until they drop at least 3 trackbacks. And after I get up date all my plugins (insert some cursing at WP here), I’m going to add a feature to LLL so I can periodically review sites that are currently “dofollowed”, that way, I can catch things retroactively. (I keep saying this… some day I’ll even do it!
)
Related Posts:
Comments
Who Doesn’t Love Daegan Spam? Or “Delete to Avoid a Google Penalty” was posted on October 17, 2007 - Filed Under Blogging Google SEO |Block Spammers From Your Trackbacks
Blogs that monetize frequently find themselves unders attack by both comment and trackback spammers. Some of these spammers are stalkers, some are weirdos so obessed with paid posts they hit the bloggers site over and over and over to "punish" them for their paid posts.
Theresa of Scribble Scratch recently described the symptoms at the postie board.
- In 48 hours, Theresa got 300 comment spams that hit only PPP posts.
- The 'comments' come through the trackback links. (That would be wp-trackback.php .)
- The direct visits to the trackback links leave proxy IPs.
What can you do? Well, of course, you should already be using Akismet, BadBehavior and Spam Karma; those will block a lot of spam. But sometimes even those don't work completely. Both Tricia and Theresa notice some of this is flying past Bad Behavior. You can also use WP-Ban to ban certain IP's after that IP spamming.
But what happens when they change IP addresses?Here's a suggestion thatmight work.
My suggestion is based on a trick I learned fromSpamHuntresses' who blocks trackback spam .htaccess. She described how to do it for WP 1.5; I modified her method make it work for me, and to also catch the spammers using proxy servers. (I've also left Spamhuntress a question because I think we can block even more spam if we add a few more lines.)
Anyway, give this a try because it may do the trick:- Visit your blog's WP directory. Find the .htaccess file. (It will have a '.' in front of htaccess. There should already be one because WP creates one. The '.' sometimes makes that file invisible, so if you can't see it, contact your host and ask them to adjust that for you.
- Important:Make a backup in case things go horribly wrong. (They shouldn't.) I named mine htaccessBackup.
- Edit your .htaccess file by cutting and pasting the text in the box below. (After pasting, make sure all quotes are straight up and down normal ones. They should be-- I've blocked WP's auto-formatting in this article.)
- Save the new .htaccess file. Check that your blog loads. If it does, you are finished. If your blog doesn't replace the edited file with your backup!
So, how does this block spam?
Well... no. Nothing can block everybit of trackback spam. But here is what it will block:- It prevents anyone using a browser to get to wp-trackback.php. That file called to leave trackback spam-- and it appears in my logs when I get a trackback. Trackbacks shouldn't be left by browsers-- but many spammers give it a try.
- It prevents anyone from accessing wp-trackback.php through a proxy server.
What else could be done?
SpamHuntress's original code had a line like this "<Files trackback>" which I replaced with "<Files wp-trackback.php>". The reason I did that is that <Files trackback> never blocked the spam for me. What I've found is that the set up she described blocked browsers from accessing addresses like this:
http://money.bigbucksblogger.com/trackback/
But not this:
http://money.bigbucksblogger.com/the_file_name/trackback/
And since my trackbacks look like the latter, not the former, her method didn't help me. But using <Files wp-trackback.php> did help me -- so it might help you.
Anyway, if you are having trouble with trackback spam, give my code a try. If it doesn't work for you, maybe we'll get lucky and someone who understands .htaccess a bit better can tell us how to fix the code and make it work for everyone. (Also, if it turns out the spam comes through pingbacks, we'll need to hunt down another solution. )
Meahwhile, good luck!
Related Posts:
- Who Doesn't Love Daegan Spam? Or "Delete to Avoid a Google Penalty"
- Blog Security: htaccess block
- What makes an A-list blogger?
- Useless Link Detector: Is it useful?